home - The Share Centre logo

Your share of investment news and views

Visit Share.com

We are saving more, and we talked about that here yesterday. Alas it appears we are not paying back mortgage debt. This is worrisome indeed. Before the finance crisis UK households had built up too much debt. In 2012 mortgage debt is as high as ever. But hope comes in the form of inflation.

As swords of Damocles go, all that mortgage debt seems pretty serious. At the beginning of 2008, the stock of mortgage debt in the UK was £1.19 trillion. Right now it’s £1.26 trillion. In other words, despite the money households are saving because lower interest rates are cutting interest payments on their mortgages, very little effort is being made to reduce the actual principal.

Yet savings rates have increased enormously. Between 2002 and 2008 savings ratios were 3.2 per cent. In the last quarter the ratio was 6.7 per cent.

So, yes, we are saving more, but we are not reducing mortgage debt.

At one level the explanation is easy to see. Households are seeing incomes squeezed. So any reduction in mortgage interest payments is gratefully received, and used to make up for all those increasing costs that households have been forced to bear in recent years.

Or to put it another way: yippee, we are better off thanks to lower interest on our mortgages. Let’s use the money we save to fund the extra money we are forking out on our petrol and utility bills.

Despite the fact that there is little evidence to suggest households are deleveraging their mortgage debt Capital Economics has some good news anyway. Thanks to inflation, mortgage debt relative to income is much smaller today than in 2008. In fact, it calculates that as a nominal percentage of disposable income, mortgage debt is now at its lowest level since 2006.

I have some observations.

Firstly, the argument that incomes are being squeezed to explain why households are not reducing mortgage debt does not totally add up. The squeezed income is not stopping households from saving, it is just stopping them from reducing mortgage debt. So isn’t that a bit odd? Most financial advisors advise you to reduce debt before you start putting money into savings schemes or into equities.

On the other hand, bearing in mind that real interest rates are negative, I am not sure that it would make sense for households to reduce debt. After all, rates are so low right now that it is incredibly cheap to service debt. In such times debt makes sense.

It is just that many households’ balance sheets are as precarious as ever. Matthew Pointon, Property Economist at Capital Economics, said: “Even so, this data suggests that many households remain in a precarious financial position. The good news is that interest rates are set to remain low for the foreseeable future, but any fresh deterioration in employment or real incomes could yet trigger another wave of mortgage payment problems.”

Or to put it another way, the sword of Damocles is still there, it is just that right now the threads on which it hangs are quite strong.

These views and comments are those of the author alone and do not necessarily reflect the view of The Share Centre, its officers and employees

Showing 1 comment

  1. Regarding debt in particular but history in general, I incline towards Leo Tolstoy’s fatalistic view. Every generation has a mind of it’s own and we can only speculate on what’s going on it other people’s minds. So waves of influence are never more than temporary ripples. Imperceptable interferences in time’s vast turbulent pool. So it is with debt. Those who grow up poor have very different ways of seeing ought to those who grow up easy, but when times are hard for everyone, it’s those with the relevent experience that usually manage best.
    I wonded how many professionals involved in shaping Britain’s future economic policy, still have unpaid Student Loans as well as large mortgages and maxed out credit cards, backed by the infallable Bank of Dad ? I can’t fault their reasoning, what do I know about them? My generation collected pennies from centimental aunties, on feast days, and took them to the Post Office to buy National Savings Stamps.
    Demarkation between the ignorant and educated (poor and rich!) in society, is no more than an optimisticaly judgemental state of mind. Both conditions are relatives, dictated by the time. We all draw our conclusions from the common pool.;

Add a comment

* - Required Field.